Michael Muska is one of the co-authors behind Getting In!, and is currently completing his first decade as Dean of College Relations at Poly Prep Country Day School in Brooklyn, New York. He previously spent six years at Brown University in Admissions and Athletics and in a similar capacity at Oberlin College in Ohio. We took a few minutes to chat with him about the current college process many students are facing and how some of these issues are discussed in Getting In!
How have you seen the college admissions and/or financial aid process change in the last decade?
It’s initially a bit frightening to see how competitive it has become to gain admission to the most elite colleges in America. That being said, there is a college space for every student in America who wants one. After you get beyond the Top 100 colleges or so, most schools are accepting more students than they deny. And the state and community college systems across the country open the door for any student who wants to attend college. Many top colleges have increased recruiting and marketing, particularly in the international sector, and this has increased their application numbers. Colleges still want to look at transcripts, read essays and recommendations and learn about your passions. We talk about this in detail in our book and try to give you insight into understanding what colleges look for today.
As we also discuss in the book, there are ways to finance your education. Many colleges are committed to meeting your financial need, and socio-economic background is as important to many colleges as diversity. Many top schools are reducing loans and increasing grants to help aid lower income and even middle class families gain access to top schools. Even with shrinking state funding, Pell Grant and federal loan programs are there for those families who need them. If anything, colleges have become more sensitive to financial need in the past decade.
You lift the curtain on a lot mysteries surround the world of higher education. What’s one of the biggest misconceptions students have about the college process that you’ve addressed in the book?
The greatest misconception I believe is that colleges are no longer looking for the well-rounded individual, but the well-rounded class. What that means is that at the more competitive schools, someone who is outstanding at one thing (academics, athletics, leadership, arts etc.) will be at an advantage over the generalist who does many things. I say find your passion – early in high school, try many things, but start to focus on one or two that early catch your interest and that you’re good at. The days of the three sport athlete have evolved to the year round specialist in one sport that colleges will recruit. Find a leadership role at your school, or care about making a difference and a college will take another look at your file. A well-rounded class simply means a community of people who are really passionate about what they do.
Many high school juniors and seniors become overwhelmed with the numerous intricacies of applying to a college. What are some of the basic resources in Getting In! students can reference as a starting point?
I think we are very thoughtful about getting started and reducing stress. The first piece we focus on is being honest and realistic with yourself. A transcript full of C’s and SAT scores in the 500’s will not get you into an Ivy League school. That self-assessment is critical in the way the college process will evolve for you. There are schools for everyone – find the ones that make sense for you.
We also talk about the concept of fit – finding a school that “fits” you. That can be academic, location, size or a combination of variables. Take the time to find realistic choices that fit you. They are out there.
What messages in Getting In! are you hoping students will take away after they’re done reading it?
As I said earlier, there is a school for everyone. Step back and evaluate your strengths and weaknesses and utilize what we say in the book to best package and present yourself in the college process. As the Zinch people say, you are more than a number – think about the message you want to share about who you are with the college and why you might be a good match for them.
For more info on Getting In! and to download Chapter 1 for free, become a fan of the Getting In! Facebook Page. If you’re looking to pick up a copy head over to Amazon where the book is currently available and in stock today!